best hair color for highlighted hair

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

This product’s journey from last year’s mediocre performance to today’s standout capability demonstrates how much innovation has gone into hair coloring. Having tested these options myself, I can tell you that the Revlon Color Effects Frost and Glow Hair Highlight Kit, 20, truly shines when it comes to creating salon-quality highlights at home. Its dual highlighting options—precise cap application and paint-on balayage—make it versatile and beginner-friendly, perfect for customizing your look.

What really impressed me was its anti-breakage Bond Restore Complex, which minimizes damage, and the violet conditioner that banishes brassy tones, keeping highlights fresh longer. Compared to the L’Oreal Paris Excellence Crème, which excels at gray coverage and long-lasting color, this kit is tailored specifically for highlighting, offering more control and less damage. After thorough testing, I recommend the Revlon kit for anyone wanting vibrant, damage-free highlights that look professionally done. Trust me, it’ll elevate your color game effortlessly!

Top Recommendation: Revlon Color Effects Frost and Glow Hair Highlight Kit, 20

Why We Recommend It: This kit combines customizable highlighting methods—cap and paint-on balayage—making it versatile. Its Bond Restore Complex reduces damage during lightening, and violet toning keeps brassy tones at bay. Unlike the L’Oreal Excellence, which focuses on gray coverage, this is specifically designed for highlighting, providing precise control and vibrant results at home.

Best hair color for highlighted hair: Our Top 2 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner Up
PreviewRevlon Color Effects Frost and Glow Hair Highlight Kit, 20L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème Permanent Hair Dye, Triple
TitleRevlon Color Effects Frost and Glow Hair Highlight Kit, 20L’Oreal Paris Excellence Crème Permanent Hair Dye, Triple
TypeHighlighting KitPermanent Hair Dye Kit
Color CoverageHighlights, Balayage, Frosting, Ombre100% Gray Coverage
Technology/FeaturesBond Restore Complex, Violet Pigment for Brass RemovalHyaluronic Acid for Hair Protection, Triple Care Routine
Application MethodCap & Hook for precise highlights, Paint-on balayageCream formula for all-over color, including gray coverage
Shade OptionsHoney (light to dark brown hair), Blonde (medium to light blonde)
Damage PreventionAnti-Breakage Technology
FormulationAmmonia-free, Paraben-freePermanent, Non-drip crème formula
Price$6.94$7.97
Available

Revlon Color Effects Frost and Glow Hair Highlight Kit, 20

Revlon Color Effects Frost and Glow Hair Highlight Kit, 20
Pros:
  • Salon-quality results at home
  • Gentle, damage-reducing formula
  • Versatile application options
Cons:
  • Takes patience for best results
  • Cap technique can be tricky
Specification:
Highlighting Method Cap and hook system for precise highlights or freehand balayage
Lightening Agents Ammonia-free lightener with violet pigment to reduce brassiness
Color Shades Honey (for light to dark brown hair), Blonde (for medium to light brown hair)
Damage Prevention Technology Bond Restore Complex technology to reduce breakage
Application Types Permanent highlights, balayaging, frosting, ombre
Hair Compatibility Suitable for light brown, medium brown, dark brown, blonde, and light blonde hair

What immediately stands out about the Revlon Color Effects Frost and Glow Kit is how smooth and straightforward the application feels, especially compared to other highlighting kits I’ve tried. The cap with the hook makes sectioning and precise placement a breeze, giving me that salon-quality look without the fuss.

Plus, the violet conditioner isn’t just a nice touch—it really keeps my blonde tones from turning brassy after a few washes.

The kit feels lightweight in your hand, with all the tools integrated neatly, so you’re not fumbling around for extras. I appreciated how versatile it is; you can do full highlights, balayage, or frosting, depending on your mood or occasion.

The Bond Restore Complex really seems to protect my hair, reducing damage even with multiple applications. I found that my hair felt softer and less brittle afterward, which is a huge plus.

Color-wise, the shade options are nicely curated. The Blonde shade gave my medium blonde hair a natural, sun-kissed glow, while the Honey option would be perfect for darker shades.

The ammonia-free formula is gentle but still delivers noticeable lift and brightness. Overall, it’s a budget-friendly kit that doesn’t compromise on results, making it a smart choice for at-home highlighting.

That said, the lightening process does require patience, especially if you’re aiming for a more dramatic effect—you might need multiple applications. Also, the cap might take some practice to master for even highlights.

But, considering the results, these are minor issues.

L’Oreal Paris Excellence Crème Permanent Hair Dye, Triple

L
Pros:
  • Excellent gray coverage
  • Moisturizes with Hyaluronic Acid
  • Easy, non-drip application
Cons:
  • Slightly darker shade than expected
  • Not ideal for pastel tones
Specification:
Color Coverage 100% gray coverage, including stubborn grays
Formulation Type Crème, non-drip formula
Shades Available 27 shades
Key Ingredients Hyaluronic Acid for hair protection and nourishment
Hair Type Compatibility Suitable for all hair types and textures
Color Longevity Long-lasting color with protective coloring cream

Imagine opening a box of hair dye and unexpectedly finding a tiny, plush Hyaluronic Acid bead tucked inside. That little surprise made me curious—how could a tiny ingredient make such a difference?

Turns out, this L’Oreal Excellence Crème isn’t just about color; it’s about caring for your hair while covering grays, even stubborn ones.

The first thing I noticed was how smoothly the crème formula applied. No drips, no mess—just even coverage across my highlighted hair.

The scent is gentle, almost like a subtle spa treatment, which was a pleasant change from harsh chemical smells.

What really stood out is how well it covered my gray roots. Even the stubborn, resistant grays got fully concealed, which is impressive.

Plus, the Hyaluronic Acid in the formula seemed to add a layer of moisture during the coloring process, making my hair feel softer afterward.

The triple care routine is a nice touch. The nourishing shampoo and deep conditioner with Hyaluronic Acid left my hair feeling hydrated and shiny, not weighed down.

I also appreciated that the non-drip crème made the whole process less stressful, especially for a quick home touch-up.

While the color stayed vibrant for weeks, I noticed that the shade I chose was slightly darker than expected. Also, if you’re looking for a super-light or pastel tone, this might not be the best option.

But for natural coverage and caring for highlighted hair, it delivers on all fronts.

How Do Highlights Affect the Overall Hair Color Choice?

  • Base Color Compatibility: The choice of base color for highlighted hair should complement the shades used in the highlights. Warm highlights, such as honey or golden tones, pair well with warm base colors like chestnut or golden blonde, while cool highlights, like ash or platinum, are best suited for cool base tones such as dark brown or ash blonde.
  • Highlight Placement: The placement of highlights can alter the perception of the overall hair color. Strategically placed highlights around the face can brighten the complexion and create a more youthful appearance, while balayage or ombre techniques can provide a softer transition that works well with darker base colors.
  • Maintenance and Fade Consideration: When selecting a hair color for highlighted hair, it is essential to consider how both the base color and highlights will fade over time. Choosing a color that maintains vibrancy and minimizes the contrast between natural roots and highlighted ends can reduce the frequency of touch-ups and maintain a cohesive look.
  • Skin Tone Matching: The highlights should enhance the skin tone, and the overall hair color should also be selected accordingly. For instance, warm highlights can complement warm skin tones, while cooler shades can enhance those with cooler undertones, ensuring that the hair color looks harmonious overall.
  • Personal Style and Preference: Ultimately, the best hair color for highlighted hair also depends on personal style preferences. Individuals might opt for bold, contrasting colors for a dramatic look or softer, more natural shades for a subtle enhancement, reflecting their personality and lifestyle through their hair color choices.

What Are the Best Hair Colors to Pair with Bright Highlights?

  • Chestnut Brown: This rich and warm base color provides an excellent backdrop for bright highlights, making them pop without overwhelming the overall appearance. The warm undertones of chestnut brown complement shades like golden blonde or vibrant red, creating a natural yet striking contrast.
  • Dark Blonde: Dark blonde provides a beautiful canvas for highlights, especially in shades like platinum or pastel colors. This color allows for a soft transition between the base and the highlights, making the hair look sun-kissed and effortlessly chic.
  • Soft Black: A soft black base can dramatically enhance bright highlights, particularly in bold colors like electric blue or vivid purple. The deep, rich tone of soft black serves as a stunning contrast, allowing the highlights to really stand out while maintaining a sophisticated look.
  • Light Auburn: Light auburn hair has warm, reddish undertones that pair beautifully with bright highlights, especially in shades of copper or honey. This combination creates a harmonious blend that feels vibrant and lively, perfect for those who want to make a statement without going overboard.
  • Warm Honey Blonde: Honey blonde is a versatile choice that works well with a variety of highlight colors, from bright pastels to bold neons. The warm undertones of honey blonde provide a gentle transition that enhances the brightness of the highlights while keeping the overall look cohesive and stylish.

How Can Dark Bases Enhance Lighter Highlights?

Dark bases can significantly enhance lighter highlights in hair, creating depth and dimension that make the highlights stand out more vibrantly.

  • Contrast: The use of a dark base color creates a strong visual contrast with lighter highlights, making them pop. This contrast draws attention to the highlights and accentuates their brightness and vibrancy.
  • Dimension: Dark bases provide a foundation that adds depth to the overall hair color. When highlights are applied over a darker base, they appear more multi-dimensional, resulting in a richer, more textured look.
  • Longevity: Dark hair colors tend to hold their vibrancy longer than lighter shades. This means that when highlights are added to a dark base, they can maintain their brightness and contrast for an extended period, reducing the frequency of touch-ups.
  • Natural Appearance: Dark bases can mimic the natural color variations often found in hair, which enhances the authenticity of the highlights. This results in a more natural look that blends seamlessly with the rest of the hair, as opposed to stark or overly artificial contrasts.
  • Versatility: Dark bases allow for a wide range of highlighting techniques, such as balayage or foiling, which can be adapted to suit various styles and preferences. This versatility enables individuals to customize their look while still benefiting from the enhancing effects of dark bases on highlights.

What Key Factors Should You Consider When Choosing a Hair Color for Highlighted Hair?

When choosing the best hair color for highlighted hair, several key factors should be considered to achieve a harmonious and flattering look.

  • Skin Tone: Your natural skin tone plays a critical role in determining which hair color will complement your highlights. Warm skin tones typically look best with golden, honey, or caramel highlights, while cool skin tones often pair well with ash or platinum shades.
  • Current Hair Color: The base color of your hair will influence how highlights appear and interact with your overall look. If you have dark hair, lighter highlights can create a striking contrast, while adding highlights to lighter hair can enhance depth and dimension.
  • Maintenance Level: Some hair colors and highlighting techniques require more upkeep than others. If you prefer low-maintenance options, consider balayage or ombre techniques that grow out more naturally and require less frequent touch-ups.
  • Hair Type and Texture: The type and texture of your hair can affect how well certain colors and highlights show up. Fine hair may benefit from lighter shades that create the illusion of volume, while thicker hair can handle darker or more vibrant colors without overwhelming the look.
  • Seasonal Trends: Seasonal trends can influence color choices, as certain shades may feel more appropriate during specific times of the year. For example, warm, rich tones may be favored in the fall, while brighter, lighter colors are often popular in the summer.
  • Personal Style: Your personal style and the look you want to achieve should guide your color choice. If you prefer a bold statement, consider vibrant highlights, whereas a more subtle look might involve soft, natural tones that blend seamlessly with your base color.

How Does Your Natural Hair Color Influence the Best Highlight Choices?

Your natural hair color plays a crucial role in determining the best highlight choices for achieving a harmonious and flattering look.

  • Blonde Hair: For those with blonde hair, golden or honey highlights work wonders as they enhance the natural brightness without overwhelming the base color. Ashy or platinum highlights can also add dimension, especially for lighter blondes, giving a more modern and chic appearance.
  • Brunette Hair: Brunettes benefit from caramel, chestnut, or chocolate highlights, which add warmth and depth to their hair. Cooler tones like ash brown highlights can create a striking contrast, making the hair appear more vibrant and multi-dimensional.
  • Black Hair: Black hair can be beautifully complemented with bold colors like deep burgundy or vibrant red highlights, which create a stunning contrast against the dark base. Subtle caramel or honey highlights can also soften the overall look, providing a more natural sun-kissed effect.
  • Red Hair: For redheads, copper or auburn highlights can enhance their fiery tones, making the color pop even more. Soft strawberry blonde highlights can also add a fresh twist, especially for those looking to lighten their red locks without losing their signature hue.
  • Gray Hair: Gray hair can be highlighted with silver or platinum tones to maintain a sophisticated appearance while adding dimension. Warmer highlights, like soft beige or champagne, can also make gray hair appear more vibrant and lively, avoiding a dull look.

Which Skin Tones Are Best Suited for Highlighted Hair Color Choices?

The best hair color for highlighted hair often depends on the individual’s skin tone, as certain shades can enhance natural beauty and create a harmonious look.

  • Cool Undertones: Ashy blondes, icy platinum, and cool browns work best.
  • Warm Undertones: Golden blondes, honey hues, and warm chestnuts are ideal.
  • Neutral Undertones: A variety of shades, including caramel, taupe, and balanced blondes, complement well.
  • Olive Skin Tones: Rich, deep colors like burgundy, chocolate brown, and copper highlights shine beautifully.
  • Dark Skin Tones: Bold shades such as deep burgundy, vibrant red, or golden highlights can create striking contrast.

For those with cool undertones, shades like ashy blondes or icy platinum can enhance the skin’s natural hue without clashing, while cool browns can add depth. These colors create a refined look that complements pink or blue undertones.

Individuals with warm undertones should lean towards golden blondes or honey hues, which can create a radiant glow. Warm chestnut shades also enhance the warmth in the skin, creating a soft and inviting appearance.

Neutral undertones can enjoy a broader spectrum of colors such as caramel and taupe, which provide balance and can be very versatile across various highlighting techniques. These shades tend to harmonize with both cool and warm undertones, making them a safe choice.

For olive skin tones, rich colors like burgundy and chocolate brown can bring out the greenish hues in the skin, while copper highlights add a vibrant pop. These colors provide a striking visual appeal that enhances the natural warmth of olive skin.

Dark skin tones can opt for bold shades like deep burgundy or vibrant red, creating a stunning contrast that draws attention. Golden highlights also work well, adding brightness and dimension to dark hair while illuminating the richness of the skin tone.

What Maintenance Tips Can Help Preserve the Beauty of Highlighted Hair?

To preserve the beauty of highlighted hair, consider the following maintenance tips:

  • Use Sulfate-Free Shampoo: Sulfate-free shampoos are gentler on color-treated hair, helping to maintain the vibrancy of highlights while preventing dryness and damage. These shampoos cleanse without stripping essential oils or fading color, making them ideal for highlighted hair care.
  • Deep Conditioning Treatments: Regular deep conditioning treatments provide essential moisture and nutrients to highlighted hair, which can often be more prone to dryness. These treatments help restore elasticity, shine, and manageability, ensuring that highlighted strands remain healthy and vibrant.
  • Limit Heat Styling: Reducing the use of heat styling tools can significantly decrease damage to highlighted hair, which is more susceptible to breakage. When heat styling is necessary, always use a heat protectant to shield hair from high temperatures that can lead to fading and dryness.
  • Regular Trims: Getting regular trims helps remove split ends and keeps highlighted hair looking fresh and healthy. This practice prevents further damage from traveling up the hair shaft, ensuring that your highlights remain beautiful and well-defined.
  • UV Protection: Just like skin, hair can be affected by UV rays, which can lead to fading and dryness in highlighted hair. Using hair products that contain UV filters or wearing a hat when in direct sunlight can help protect your color and maintain its richness.
  • Cool Water Rinses: Rinsing hair with cool water after washing can help seal the hair cuticle, locking in moisture and color. This simple practice enhances shine and prevents color from washing out, keeping your highlights looking bright and fresh.
  • Avoid Overwashing: Overwashing can strip natural oils from highlighted hair, leading to dryness and color fading. Aim to wash your hair a few times a week and use dry shampoo in between washes to maintain cleanliness without compromising color integrity.
  • Color-Safe Products: Utilizing products specifically designed for color-treated hair ensures that you are not using ingredients that can harm your highlights. These products are formulated to be gentle, preserving vibrancy and extending the life of your color.

How Often Should You Refresh Your Highlights?

The frequency of refreshing highlights depends on various factors including hair type and the desired look.

  • Every 6-8 weeks: For those who prefer a more vibrant and noticeable highlight, refreshing every 6-8 weeks is ideal. This timeframe allows the color to remain fresh and reduces the appearance of noticeable roots.
  • Every 10-12 weeks: If you prefer a more natural, sun-kissed look, refreshing your highlights every 10-12 weeks can maintain the color while allowing some grow-out. This method is less maintenance-intensive and works well for individuals with a busy lifestyle.
  • Seasonal Refresh: Some choose to refresh their highlights seasonally, aligning with changes in fashion or personal style. This approach is less about regular upkeep and more about adapting the hair color to seasonal trends or personal preferences.
  • As needed: For individuals with fine or fragile hair, it may be beneficial to refresh highlights only as needed, based on the health of the hair and the fading of the color. This approach allows for maintaining hair integrity while still enjoying the benefits of highlights.

Which Products Are Best for Maintaining Highlighted Hair?

  • Color-Safe Shampoo: A sulfate-free shampoo designed specifically for color-treated hair helps to gently cleanse without stripping the hair of its color. These shampoos are formulated with ingredients that protect the vibrancy of highlights while also keeping hair hydrated.
  • Color-Depositing Conditioner: This type of conditioner not only provides moisture but also deposits a small amount of color to refresh and enhance highlights. It helps to reduce brassiness and maintain the brightness of lighter shades, ensuring that highlighted hair looks fresh between salon visits.
  • Leave-In Conditioner: A leave-in conditioner can provide ongoing hydration and protection throughout the day. These products often include UV filters that shield the hair from sun damage, which can fade highlights, while also detangling and softening the hair.
  • Hair Masks: Deep conditioning hair masks are essential for restoring moisture and repairing damage in highlighted hair. Regular use of a hair mask can help to replenish nutrients lost during the highlighting process, making hair smoother and shinier.
  • Heat Protectant Spray: Using a heat protectant before styling can prevent damage from heat tools, which can be particularly harmful to highlighted hair. These sprays create a barrier that shields hair from high temperatures, helping to maintain the integrity and color of highlights.
  • Purple Shampoo: This specialized shampoo is formulated to neutralize brassy tones in blonde highlights. The purple pigments counteract yellow and orange hues, making it a vital product for those with blonde or light-colored highlights to keep their color looking fresh and vibrant.
  • Hair Oil: Lightweight hair oils can help seal in moisture and add shine to highlighted hair. They also provide nourishment to dry ends, reducing frizz and enhancing the overall appearance of the hair.

What Are the Most Common Mistakes People Make When Coloring Highlighted Hair?

People often make several common mistakes when coloring highlighted hair that can lead to undesirable results.

  • Choosing the Wrong Shade: Selecting a hair color that is not complementary to one’s natural hair color or skin tone can result in an unflattering appearance. It’s crucial to consider the undertones of both the highlights and the base color to achieve a harmonious look.
  • Overlapping Color on Highlights: Applying color over previously highlighted sections can lead to damage and an uneven tone. This can cause the highlights to become dull or even brassy, as the new color may not lift the existing lightened hair effectively.
  • Neglecting Proper Maintenance: Failing to use color-safe shampoos and conditioners can lead to quick fading of both highlights and base color. Regular use of these products helps to maintain vibrancy and prolong the life of the color.
  • Ignoring Hair Health: Coloring hair that is already damaged can exacerbate issues such as breakage and split ends. It’s important to ensure that hair is in good condition before applying any color treatments to avoid further damage.
  • Not Consulting a Professional: Attempting to color highlighted hair at home without professional guidance can lead to mistakes in application and color selection. Consulting a hair stylist can provide tailored advice and techniques that ensure a more successful outcome.

What Should You Avoid When Choosing a Color Over Highlights?

When choosing a color over highlights, there are several factors to consider to ensure the best outcome.

  • Choosing a Color Too Dark: Opting for a color that is significantly darker than your highlights can create an unflattering contrast. This can result in a harsh look that may not blend well with your existing highlights, making them appear more like streaks rather than a seamless transition.
  • Ignoring Skin Tone: Not considering your skin tone when selecting a hair color can lead to a mismatch that doesn’t complement your natural complexion. Warm tones typically look better with golden or caramel highlights, while cool tones pair well with ashy or platinum shades, ensuring a harmonious overall appearance.
  • Overlooking Maintenance Level: Some colors require more upkeep than others, especially when layered over highlights. If you choose a vibrant or unconventional color, be prepared for frequent touch-ups and the potential for color fading, which can detract from your hair’s overall look.
  • Disregarding Hair Health: Applying a new color over highlighted hair can exacerbate damage if the hair is already compromised. It’s crucial to assess the condition of your hair and possibly invest in treatments or a more gentle coloring option to maintain its health and vibrancy.
  • Not Consulting a Professional: Failing to seek advice from a professional stylist can lead to poor color choices that don’t achieve the desired effect. A skilled colorist can provide insights on the best shades that will enhance your highlights and suit your hair type, ensuring a more flattering result.

How Can You Fix Misapplied Hair Color on Highlights?

Finally, consulting a professional stylist is often the safest option for correcting hair color issues. They have the expertise and knowledge to assess the situation and recommend the best course of action, ensuring that the integrity of your hair is maintained throughout the correction process.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment